Why Your App Paywall Isn't Converting (And How To Fix It)
The short answer
App paywall: four fixes that get more people to start a trial
A paywall converts better when it sells what the person just made, not a features list. Pre-select the plan your category buys most (yearly for fitness), make the billed price the most prominent on every row, show the user's own plan, and give the trial its own line with a reminder promise. Modelled for one fictional app, that took trials from about 230 to 256 a month.
Key facts
- 68%Of Health and Fitness subscriptions sold are yearly, about 2 in every 3.RevenueCat, State of Subscription Apps 2026
- 15 to 20 pointsHow much the yearly share of subscriptions rose when Mojo showed only the yearly plan and put monthly behind a link.RevenueCat blog, How Mojo achieved a remarkable 60% increase in ARPU in just five months, 12 October 2023
- +41%More trials from paywalls matched to the keyword a user searched, against each app's default paywall, in Adapty's Apple Ads data (vendor data).Adapty blog, Does paywall personalization work for Apple Ads?, 15 June 2026
- +23%Trial sign-ups at Blinkist after its paywall was built around the trial timeline and a reminder promise. One app's result, so Cobalt counts half.Growth.Design, How To Increase Trial Conversions by 23% (Ethically)
Chapters
- 0:00This app paywall sells the wrong thing
- 0:36What is Cobalt's paywall really selling?
- 1:18Fix one: pre-select the plan people buy
- 2:19How big should the yearly price be?
- 3:08Sell the plan, not the features
- 4:15What happens after Alex taps?
- 5:15How many more trials does one screen buy?
- 6:10Is one screen enough?
Transcript
Edited for readingCobalt is a fictional workout app built for this series, and Alex is a made-up test user; the screens are illustrative and the scoreboard is modelled from the sources below, not measured.
This app paywall sells the wrong thingWatch from 0:00
This app paywall sells features to someone who just built a plan. In Cobalt, a made-up workout app, Alex just built a 12-week strength plan. One tap later, the paywall forgets it.
Right now, about 1 in 35 people who download Cobalt start a trial.
Three things are wrong. It sells features, not the plan. It picks the wrong plan for you. And it hides what happens after the trial.
If people install your app but few start a trial, this is your screen. We fix all three, plus one problem the first fix creates. Then we count what it's worth in trials.
What is Cobalt's paywall really selling?Watch from 0:36
Start with the prices. Weekly is already ticked, for everyone who lands here.
In fitness apps, about 2 in every 3 subscriptions sold are yearly. Cobalt's default points everyone at weekly. Fitness apps rarely sell it.
Above the prices, a features list. Unlimited workouts, custom programs, priority support. Not one word of Alex's plan.
Then Alex looks for the trial. It's there, but only inside a small paragraph of legal text.
So Alex is asked to buy a features list, on a rarely bought plan, with the trial hidden. The default is the easiest thing to change, so it goes first.
Fix one: pre-select the plan people buyWatch from 1:18
Fix one. Yearly becomes the default, with a best value badge. Monthly and weekly stay right there, one tap away.
Prices stay the same, and so does the 3-day trial. It now simply follows whichever plan is selected.
Does what's ticked change what people pick? Mojo, a video editing app, tested a stronger version. It showed only the yearly plan and tucked monthly behind a link. The share of subscriptions that were yearly rose 15 to 20 points.
Cobalt's change is weaker. Mojo hid monthly, and that turned out to be what mattered. Cobalt keeps every plan visible and only moves the tick, so expect less.
For Alex, it fits. Someone starting a 12-week plan now sees the long plan ticked, not the weekly one.
Our take: pre-select the plan your category buys most, and keep the others easy to find.
But the new default brings a new problem. Next to the weekly price, the yearly one suddenly looks big.
How big should the yearly price be?Watch from 2:19
Fix two is how the price reads. The tempting move is to flip it. Make the per-week price huge, and tuck the yearly total underneath. It looks cheaper. It also breaks Apple's rules.
Apple's rule: the amount you'll be billed must be the most prominent price on the screen. That's $59.99 a year, not $1.15 a week.
The per-week figure can stay. It just sits smaller, underneath, as a translation. The price you're charged leads on every row. Any breakdown sits underneath.
Alex can read the whole offer in one glance, and the charge is clear before the tap.
Two fixes in, and Cobalt's trial count hasn't moved. The next two are the ones that count.
Sell the plan, not the featuresWatch from 3:08
Fix three. The features list goes. In its place, the plan Alex just made. A ring of twelve weeks. A headline: your 12-week strength plan is ready. And Alex's own answers underneath. Three times a week, 20 minutes, no equipment.
Alex sees the plan again, one tap after making it. The paywall picks up exactly where onboarding left off.
The features are all still in the app. The paywall just stops listing them, and shows what Alex gets instead.
Is there evidence that matching a paywall to what someone wants works? Adapty, a paywall tool, looked at Apple Ads installs. It compared paywalls matched to the keyword a user searched with each app's default paywall. The matched ones started 41% more trials.
Cobalt matches the paywall to the plan Alex built instead. Same idea, not the same test, so it doesn't promise Cobalt that lift.
Our take: the strongest thing a paywall can sell is something the person already made.
So the top of the screen sells the plan. But the bottom still hides what happens after Alex taps.
What happens after Alex taps?Watch from 4:15
Fix four. The trial leaves the legal text and gets its own line, right above the button. It promises a reminder before the trial ends. Under the button, the price after the trial, and that you can cancel anytime.
Before, Alex had to read a whole paragraph to learn any of this. Now it's three short lines.
One catch: the reminder is a notification. If Alex turned those off, Cobalt asks again as the trial starts, now with a reason.
Blinkist, the reading app from our video Why Your Paywall Design Is Losing Sales (And How To Fix It), tested exactly this. It built its paywall around the trial timeline and a reminder promise. Trial sign-ups rose 23%. That's one app's result, so Cobalt counts half.
And the close button is easy to see now.
That's four changes on one screen. Now the question from the start: what are they worth in trials?
How many more trials does one screen buy?Watch from 5:15
Here's Alex's path again, the old paywall beside the new one.
Four changes, but Cobalt doesn't stack four lifts. The whole screen gets one: half of Blinkist's result. It's the closest published test to this change, and halved, it's a cautious figure.
The yearly default isn't counted at all. It changes which plan people pick. This line only counts who starts.
Cobalt starts at about 230 trials a month. Pause and guess where one screen takes it. The model says about 256. Same downloads. One screen.
What this can't tell you. Blinkist is one reading app, tested years ago. Cobalt changed four things at once, so the real effect could be bigger or smaller. And the reminder only helps if it arrives. A real team would ship this as a split test, and read it on trial starts.
Is one screen enough?Watch from 6:10
So is it enough? Not even close. From the same downloads, a typical fitness app gets about 550. One screen closes a small piece of that gap. The rest is about the prices themselves.
Cobalt's paywall finally sells the plan Alex just made.
Sources
- RevenueCat, State of Subscription Apps 2026
- RevenueCat blog, How Mojo achieved a remarkable 60% increase in ARPU in just five months (12 October 2023)
- Apple Developer, Auto-renewable subscriptions
- Apple, App Review Guidelines 3.1.2
- Google Play Console Help, Subscriptions
- Adapty blog, Does paywall personalization work for Apple Ads? (15 June 2026)
- Growth.Design, How To Increase Trial Conversions by 23% (Ethically)
- Lazyweb Research, What % of Paywalls Pre-Select the Annual Plan? (7 July 2026)
Caveat: Cobalt's numbers are Appelune calculations from its modelled month (8,000 downloads, about 230 trials after the onboarding fix, 26.1% trial to paid). The whole screen gets one lift, +11.5% trial starts: half of Blinkist's single-app +23%. Trial to paid and prices are unchanged; the yearly default is not counted in 60-day revenue. Modelled result: 230 to about 256 trials a month, 60 to 67 payers, $0.24 to $0.26 revenue per install by day 60, $1,915 to $2,060 60-day revenue. Vendors publish their wins, and the four changes were not tested one at a time.

